Background
In 2014, J.P. faced serious charges of second-degree assault with a deadly weapon and terroristic threats in Dakota County. While it was clear that J.P. was guilty of the terroristic threats charge, defense attorney Ryan Pacyga was convinced that J.P. was not guilty of the more serious charge of second-degree assault. A conviction on this charge would carry severe penalties, including a felony record and potential jail time.
Challenge
The stakes were high for J.P., as a conviction for second-degree assault with a deadly weapon would have far-reaching consequences. While there was no dispute regarding the terroristic threats charge, Ryan Pacyga had to take the case to trial to defend J.P. against the assault charge, seeking a favorable outcome that would minimize the impact on her future.
Defense Strategy
Ryan Pacyga’s strategy was to focus on disproving the second-degree assault charge while accepting responsibility for the terroristic threats. He meticulously prepared the defense, presenting evidence and arguments that challenged the prosecution’s case on the assault charge. Throughout the trial, Ryan skillfully demonstrated to the jury that while his client may have made threats, the allegations of using a deadly weapon in an assault were unfounded.
Simultaneously, Ryan filed a motion for a downward dispositional departure on the terroristic threats charge, aiming to secure a more lenient sentence that would avoid jail time and a felony conviction for J.P.
Outcome
The jury found J.P. not guilty of second-degree assault with a deadly weapon, a significant victory that spared her from a felony conviction and the severe penalties associated with the charge. Furthermore, the judge granted Ryan Pacyga’s motion for a downward dispositional departure on the terroristic threats charge, allowing J.P. to avoid both a felony conviction and jail time.
Conclusion
In State v. J.P., Ryan Pacyga’s trial strategy led to a crucial acquittal on the most serious charge of second-degree assault and a favorable sentencing outcome on the terroristic threats charge. By successfully defending against the assault allegation and securing a downward departure, Ryan helped J.P. avoid a felony record and imprisonment, allowing her to move forward without the heavy burden of a serious criminal conviction. This case highlights the importance of effective trial advocacy and strategic sentencing arguments in criminal defense.